Getting a bad review from someone who was never actually a customer is a frustrating experience. You know it's not real, but there it sits on your profile, pulling your rating down and potentially putting people off before they've even walked through the door.
It's more common than most business owners realise. Competitors do it. Disgruntled ex-employees do it. Sometimes it's just a case of mistaken identity, someone reviewing the wrong business entirely. Whatever the reason, it's worth knowing how to spot them and what you can actually do.
No single thing confirms a review is fake, but a few things together start to paint a picture.
Click on the profile of anyone who leaves you a review. If the account was created recently, has no photo, and your business is the only review they've ever left, that's worth noting. Real customers tend to have some kind of history on Google, even if it's just a few reviews from years back.
A review that mentions something specific that didn't happen, a dish you don't serve, a member of staff with the wrong name, or a date when you were closed, is a reasonable indicator that the person wasn't actually there. Not definitive, but worth flagging.
Getting two or three one-star reviews in the space of a day or two, especially from accounts with no history, suggests something coordinated. It happens, particularly in competitive industries. A pattern is more meaningful than a single suspicious review.
Real complaints tend to be specific because they come from a real experience. "Terrible place, avoid" with nothing else to back it up is a weaker review in every sense. It doesn't mean it's definitely fake, but genuine complaints usually have a bit more to them.
This is where a lot of business owners get frustrated, because the honest answer is that Google doesn't make it easy.
You can report a review directly through Google Business Profile. Click the three dots next to the review and select "Report review." Google will look at it against their content policies. Grounds for removal include things like spam, fake content, conflict of interest, and off-topic content.
The catch is that Google doesn't remove reviews quickly and doesn't always remove them at all. They won't take your word for it that someone wasn't a real customer. The process can take weeks and sometimes ends with the review staying up.
This is probably the most practically useful thing you can do, even while you're waiting to see if the report goes anywhere. A calm, professional response that gently notes you have no record of the visit, and invites the reviewer to get in touch if there's been a mix-up, does a reasonable amount of work.
It shows anyone reading that you're on top of your reviews. It signals confidence rather than defensiveness. And it gives other customers context without you having to accuse anyone of anything directly.
"Thank you for leaving a review. We have checked our records and cannot find any visit matching your details. If there has been a mix-up or you visited one of our other locations, please get in touch directly and we will be happy to help."
Screenshot the review, note the date it appeared, and save the reviewer's profile details before reporting it. If the review does get removed Google won't tell you much about why, but having a record helps if the pattern continues or if you need to escalate.
If your initial report is rejected and you're confident the review is fake, you can submit a one-time appeal through Google Business Profile. It doesn't always work but it's worth trying if the review is having a noticeable impact on your rating.
Getting into an argument in the comments is probably the worst option, even if you're completely in the right. Anyone reading the exchange is going to form an impression of how you handle conflict, and a business owner who looks like they're losing their temper over a review doesn't come across well.
Buying positive reviews to dilute the fake ones is also a bad idea. Google can detect patterns in review behaviour and it's against their policies. It can make things worse, not better.
Google's review removal process is slow and inconsistent. Some fake reviews get taken down within a few days. Others sit there for months regardless of how many times you report them. It's genuinely frustrating and there's not much you can do to speed it up.
What you can control is how you respond while you wait. A well written public response to a suspicious review, one that's calm and professional without being defensive, does more for your reputation than you might expect.
Most customers reading your reviews are reasonable people. They can usually tell the difference between a genuine complaint and something that doesn't quite ring true. Your response helps them make that call.
Paste it in and get a professional, human-sounding response in about 30 seconds. Two free responses to try it out.
Try Fix My Review free →